Ask most Sanibel visitors where to eat and you will hear the same names – the usual spots clustered along Periwinkle Way with 45-minute waits and menus designed for tourists. There is nothing wrong with those restaurants, but if you are looking for something different – better food, better views, and a fraction of the crowd – you need to make the short drive to Sand Castle Road.
The Dunes Golf and Tennis Club is not just a sports facility. It is home to one of the most underrated dining experiences on the island, and yes, it is open to the public.
The Setting
The Clubhouse sits at the edge of the 18th fairway, overlooking a chain of lakes that catch the late-afternoon light in a way that is hard to describe until you have seen it. The patio has become a go-to gathering spot for islanders and visitors alike – the kind of place where you settle in with a drink, realize an hour has passed, and do not mind at all.
Inside, the dining room is comfortable without trying too hard. It is the atmosphere of a well-run club: clean, relaxed, and staffed by people who remember your name after your second visit.
The Food
Executive Chef Roro has built a menu that balances island-casual with genuine culinary ambition. This is not reheated-from-a-bag clubhouse food. Everything is made in-house, and it shows.
For lunch (served daily 11am-3pm), the standouts include the coconut shrimp – black tiger shrimp in natural shredded coconut with orange marmalade – and the signature steak sandwich, char-grilled with caramelized onions and a gorgonzola cheese fondue on ciabatta. The crab cake sandwich with house-made remoulade is another regular favorite, and the domestic red grouper (fried, grilled, or blackened) is the kind of dish that brings people back the next day.
The Angus burger has developed its own reputation on the island. One longtime TripAdvisor reviewer called it arguably the best burger in all of Southwest Florida. That is a big claim in a region with no shortage of competition, but after you try it, you will understand why people feel strongly about it.
For dinner (Monday and Friday, 5:30-8:30pm with live music), the menu shifts into something more elevated. The Scottish key lime salmon – pan-seared with a key lime sauce – is a signature dish. The char-grilled filet mignon with bourbon demi-glace and the rosemary rack of lamb with mint jelly are the kind of entrees you would expect at a high-end steakhouse, served here with lake views and a live musician playing in the background.
Friday night is prime rib night: certified Black Angus, slow-roasted, with creamy horseradish and demi de viand. It has become something of a tradition for both members and visitors who know about it.
For lighter appetites, the seafood-forward options shine – bacon-wrapped scallops with tamarind glaze to start, followed by the Frutti di Mare (shrimp, scallops, snow crab, artichoke, sun-dried tomato, and spinach in a garlic cream sauce over penne).
Happy Hour: The Island’s Best-Kept Secret
Every day from 3 to 6pm, The Dunes runs happy hour with appetizers and salads available between lunch and dinner. Here is why it works so well: by mid-afternoon, the golfers and tennis players are finishing up, the patio catches the golden-hour light, and you can settle in with a drink and a plate of spring rolls or a Caesar salad while watching the sun work its way toward the horizon.
It is the kind of afternoon ritual that makes you think about what it would be like to live on this island – or at least visit a lot more often.
Social Events and Live Music
The Dunes Clubhouse regularly hosts social gatherings that are open to both members and visitors: seasonal dinners, trivia nights, themed parties, and holiday events. It is a more intimate social scene than what you will find at the larger beach resorts, and it is where a lot of islanders actually spend their evenings.
Monday and Friday dinner nights feature live music, which gives the patio a relaxed energy that is hard to find elsewhere on Sanibel. It is not a loud scene – it is conversation-friendly, with music that adds to the atmosphere rather than competing with it.
Why Visitors Keep Coming Back
The Clubhouse is often the part of The Dunes that turns casual visitors into repeat guests. Someone books a tee time, has lunch afterward, and realizes the whole experience – the course, the food, the view, the vibe – is something they want more of.
That is why a significant number of annual members at The Dunes started as visitors. They came for a round or a meal, came back the next year, and eventually did the math: a membership (starting at $6,240 for a single) includes 15% off all dining, complimentary pool access, member rates on courts and greens fees, exclusive event invitations, and the kind of community that forms when the same people keep showing up to the same great place.
But you do not need a membership to enjoy it. Walk in, grab a table on the patio, and see what you have been missing.
Visit The Dunes Clubhouse
Address: 949 Sand Castle Rd, Sanibel, FL 33957 Phone: (239) 472-3355 Lunch: Daily, 11am-3pm Appetizers and Salads: Daily, 3-6pm Dinner: Monday and Friday, 5:30-8:30pm (live music) Reservations: Recommended for dinner; call the clubhouse or stop by
View the full lunch menu | View the dinner menu
Enjoying The Dunes? Learn how membership can make every visit even better.